Monday, November 30, 2020

COVID Crisis in BOP Puts New Emphasis on Clemency Process; Biden Promises Reform

 

"Will He or Won't He?" Multiple Election Lawsuits Might Delay Pardons, Commutations

 

by Derek Gilna

 

            By all estimates there are at least 13,000 pending commutation petitions either at DOJ or at the White House, awaiting presidential action, but there is concern that the pending lawsuits contesting vote results are slowing the process. When Jared Kushner returns from negotiations in the Middle East in the next several days, the logjam will break. It would be a good finish to 4 years of progress, and pressure Biden to top it.

            Biden has pledged to allocate billions of dollars of funding toward a grant program aimed at promoting crime prevention within state and local governments to reduce the source of crime: poor neighborhoods, child abuse, and limited education access, according to the Biden-Harris Transition plan. Biden says he could reduce the U.S. prison population by more than 50% by reducing or elimination MM's,  and  pledged to invest billions of dollars in a grant program aimed at promoting crime prevention within state and local governments.

            Ft. Dix, the focus of numerous articles, Congressional inquiry, and television coverage, has the dubious distinction of having the most "confirmed" COVID-19 cases, 232, (with perhaps hundreds more unconfirmed) of any federal facility, although the DOJ's inability or unwillingness to universally test makes me think that there are many that have similar numbers. There is also serious scientific doubt as to the health status of those who have "recovered," since many continue to experience serious side effects. It is clear that DOJ has no plan to eradicate the virus, and will not be able to for many months, especially since prisoners are unlikely to even see the vaccine until well into 2021.

            Although in terms of raw numbers, the situation at FPC Duluth may not seem high, it is a microcosm of poor DOJ planning and treatment failures. Duluth, one of the few camps not attached to a higher-security facility, is the northern-most federal prison, in an area of the country untouched by COVID-19 for many months. Lulled into a false sense of security, DOJ bragged in court filings that it was "managing" the virus, recent transfers, sloppy procedures, and botched "quarantines"  has resulted in infected prisoners sleeping on cots in an unheated gym, while staff moves from infected to uninfected dorms without concern for DOJ protocols.  What the numbers are is anyone's guess, but out of a population of 500, it could also be as high as 200, an avoidable crisis.

            Nearly 25% of all inmate cases and 30% of the staff cases have been reported within just the last month. Weekly case report: Alderson, 20 and climbing;  McDowell, over 29; Gilmer, 100+; Ashland, over 181; FMC Lexington and Atwood, 317 (12 deaths); Forrest City, 50+; Aliceville, 100 plus; Ashland, 200+; Duluth, 100+; Hazelton, 10+. So far, heavy DOJ censorship on virus news has only slowed, not ended reports.

            In U.S. v. Green, 17-10346, 11-25-20,  the 11th Circuit found that RICO conspiracy "does not qualify as a crime of violence under 924cm and vacate...and remand." The 7th Circuit slapped down DOJ's argument that the old regulations and SC statements on CR still apply, citing the 2d Circuits Booker decision to follow only the "extraordinary and compelling reason" in deciding whether to grant relief.

            Let not your heart be troubled.

Federal Legal Center, Inc., Derek A. Gilna, JD, MARJ, Director

113 McHenry Rd. #173, Buffalo Grove, IL   60089 (And Indiana)

dgilna1948@yahoo.com, blogging at "Derek Gilna's Criminal Justice Blog."